Introduction

From 1789 to the present, there have been 108 Justices of the United States Supreme Court. Depending on which source is consulted, 34, 36, 38, or 40 of them have been Freemasons. This means about one-third of the Supreme Court Justices were Masons, a far larger proportion than in the general population.

Supreme Court Justices Who Were Freemasons

Two Supreme Court Justices were Grand Masters of Virginia. John Blair, Jr., was a Justice of the United States Supreme Court from 1789 to 1796. Previously he was Grand Master of Virginia from 1778 to 1784. John Marshall, the greatest Chief Justice of the United States, was in that position from 1801 to 1835. He was also Grand Master of Virginia, from 1793-1795. (However, there is evidence that John Marshall was not proud or enthusiastic about being a Freemason, at least later in his life.)

Another Chief Justice who had a great impact on our country, Earl Warren, served from 1953 to 1969. He was Grand Master of California 1935 to 1936. He was also Potentate of Aahmes Shrine, and a 33rd degree Scottish Rite Mason and an officer in two of the Scottish Rite bodies, in Oakland, California.

William H. Taft became a Mason "at sight" in 1909, while he was President of the United States and before he became Chief Justice. Although he did not become a Mason in the traditional way, it is reported that he made many visits to Lodge meetings, participated in Masonic ceremonies, and attended meetings of the George Washington Masonic National Memorial Association.

Robert Trimble, an Associate Justice of the Supreme Court from 1826 to 1828, was Master of his lodge, Union #16 in Paris, Kentucky. Henry Baldwin, Associate Justice from 1830 to 1844, was Master of Lodge #45 in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, in 1805. Joseph R. Lamar, Associate Justice from 1910 to 1916, was Senior Warden of Webb Lodge #166 in Augusta, Georgia, in 1885, but apparently did not become Master of the Lodge.

Many of the Supreme Court Justices who were Freemasons also were members of their local Royal Arch Chapters, Cryptic or Royal and Select Master Councils, Knight Templar Commanderies, Scottish Rite bodies, Shrines, and Grottoes.

Stanley Matthews, Associate Justice from 1881-1889, became a Mason in 1847, but demitted in 1856, long before he served on the Supreme Court.

William R. Denslow's book, 10,000 Famous Freemasons, identifies a total of 38 Supreme Court Justices who were Masons, often giving their lodges and the dates of their degrees. Allen E. Roberts' book, Masonic Trivia and Facts, says that Ronald E. Heaton compiled a list of 39 Supreme Court Justices who were Freemasons, and a 1940s study in the possession of MSA lists 34. Some of these sources list as Masons those who are not listed by others. If we rely on any of these sources for our list of Supreme Court Justices who were Freemasons, we get a total of 40.

The following chart lists the Supreme Court Justices who are identified by one or more sources as having been Freemasons.

     
Name   Dates of Service
John Jay Chief Justice 1789-1795
John Rutledge Chief Justice 1789-1791, 1795
William Cushing   1789-1810
John Blair, Jr.   1789-1796
William Paterson   1793-1806
Oliver Ellsworth Chief Justice 1796-1800
John Marshall Chief Justice 1801-1835
Thomas Todd   1807-1826
Joseph Story   1811-1845
Robert Trimble   1826-1828
John McLean   1829-1861
Henry Baldwin 1830-1844
John Catron   1837-1865
Samuel Nelson   1845-1872
Levi Woodbury   1845-1851
Noah H. Swayne   1862-1881
David Davis   1862-1877
Stephen J. Field 1863-1897  
John M. Harlan   1877-1911
William B. Woods   1880-1887
Stanley Matthews   1881-1889
Samuel Blatchford   1882-1893
William H. Moody   1906-1910
Willis Van Devanter   1910-1937
Joseph R. Lamar   1910-1916
Mahlon Pitney   1912-1922
John H. Clarke   1916-1922
William H. Taft Chief Justice 1921-1930
Hugo L. Black   1937-1971
Stanley F. Reed   1938-1957
William O. Douglas   1939-1975
James F. Byrnes   1941-1942
Robert H. Jackson   1941-1954
Wiley B. Rutledge   1943-1949
Harold H. Burton   1945-1958
Fred M. Vinson Chief Justice 1946-1953
Tom C. Clark   1949-1967
Sherman Minton   1949-1956
Earl Warren Chief Justice 1953-1969
Potter C. Stewart   1958-1981
Thurgood Marshall   1967-1991
 

Notes:

10,000 Famous Freemasons quotes evidence that John Jay was a Freemason, but says there is no proof. The MSA 1940s study also indicates Jay was a Mason, but says it has not yet been discovered in which lodge.

John Rutledge became Chief Justice while the Senate was not in session, and when they reconvened he was rejected. Still, he did serve for a time in that position. Masonic Trivia and Facts and The MSA 1940s study say he was a Mason, without identifying his lodge, but 10,000 Famous Freemasons does not list him.

William Cushing is listed in 10,000 Famous Freemason as having been a member of St. Andrew's Lodge in Boston. He was offered the post of Chief Justice but chose instead to continue as an Associate Justice of the Supreme Court.

Joseph Story is listed as a member of Philanthropic Lodge in Marblehead, Massachusetts, in 10,000 Famous Freemasons and the MSA 1940s study, but not in Masonic Trivia and Facts.

John McLean is listed in 10,000 Famous Freemasons as having been a member of Columbus Lodge #30 in Columbus, Ohio, but he is not listed in Masonic Trivia and Facts or in the The MSA 1940s study.

Levi Woodbury is listed as a Mason in Masonic Trivia and Facts, but is not listed in 10,000 Famous Freemasons or in the MSA 1940s study.

David Davis, a close friend of Abraham Lincoln's, is listed in 10,000 Famous Freemasons as having been buried with Masonic ceremonies in Bloomington, Illinois. He is not listed in the other sources as having been a Freemason.

Mahlon Pitney is listed in the MSA 1940s study as having been a member of Cincinnati Lodge #3 in Morristown, New Jersey, but he is not listed in 10,000 Famous Freemasons or in Masonic Trivia and Facts.

Thurgood Marshall is listed in 10,000 Famous Freemasons as having been a director and counselor or the Prince Hall Grand Master Conference, and a 33rd degree Scottish Rite Mason.

 
 
Ararat Shrine Temple